A proposal for an apartment complex on West Broad Street, mixing old construction with new, was met with skepticism from the Bethlehem Planning Commission, and outrage from neighbors July 18.

The lots, at 817, 821-823 W. Broad St., presently each contain a building. Architect Gary Lader of 4/4 Architects spoke on behalf of owner Marco Andretti. He presented a sketch plan of the site. It showed the two existing buildings, with a four-story apartment block rising behind them.

The plan included four apartments in each of the three existing structures, and 18 in the addition, which would be raised on piers to allow parking below. A driveway would extend across the property from West Broad to Schaffer Street.

The sketch plan was created with Zoning variance requests included. These will eventually be taking to the city’s Zoning Hearing Board. Parking would include 25 spaces instead of 40. The unit density permits 18 dwelling units. Side and rear yard size reductions would also be needed.

Craig Pfeifer reminded everyone that a sketch plan is preliminary, and was being presented to get feedback from the community.

Zoning in the CL District requires a commercial use on the first floor, Pfeiffer noted, but he did say, “The city does commend the preservation of the two buildings.”

Melosky said, “The design does not blend or meld with the current feel and vibe of West Broad Street.”

Resident Kathleen Russo, who lives at 540 W. Broad, pointed out a flaw: Her lot and the lot to the north were reversed on the plan, and the requested relief would cause the complex to encroach on her property.

Melosky immediately assured Russo that the “property lines will be clarified.”

Resident Douglas Jones was concerned about the access for fire trucks to the rear of the complex.

Fred J. Chamberlain IV, who owns Resources Counsling, called the 16 unit building “The monolith in the back,” and said it would “change the look of the neighborhood.”

Several residents wondered where the rest of the cars would end up. Kathy Bowman of Seventh Avenue also reminded planners that Shaffer Street is a narrow alley.

Melosky said he would not support a building that size, raised on pillars, behind what exists now.

Malozy added, “The design is out of context with the neighborhood, too dense.“

Rader said he was grateful for the comments, which will be shared with the owner.

The August meeting of the planning board is scheduled for Aug. 15 at 5 p.m.